Car loans, student loans, lines of credit and credit cards

From the All the Numbers wiki · Cash and where it goes

Debts other than a mortgage take money out of every month until they are paid, and a lender counts them when you ask for a mortgage. The plan treats each one as a loan, not as a fixed monthly cost that never ends.

How a debt is paid off

  • Interest each month. The debt is charged its yearly rate divided by 12 on what is owed, then the monthly payment comes out of cash.[1] When the balance reaches nil the payments stop, and that money stays in the plan.
  • The rate and payment stay as entered. A variable rate, a payment that changes with the balance, and new spending on a card are not modelled.[1]
  • A payment below the interest never pays the debt off. The balance then grows each month, and the plan shows that.

Paying a debt down with a sum

Simulation's "Where should your next dollar go?" compares putting a sum into each account with paying it off each debt, and off the mortgage on a home you already own. The sum comes off what you owe in January of the plan's first year, up to the balance; anything left stays in cash. The payment stays the same, so the loan is paid off sooner. A mortgage given by its years left keeps those years, so its payment falls instead. A lump sum on a mortgage is taken as within what the lender allows each year without a penalty.[2]

A debt known only by its payment

A plan saved before debts were loans held only a monthly payment, and the start questions let you give a payment without a balance. Such a debt is taken as 60 months of that payment at no interest, until you enter what you owe and the rate. An older plan's living expenses lose the same payment, since they used to include it, so its spending is unchanged until the loan is paid.[3]

Credit cards

A credit card charges interest on the daily balance, posted each month; over a month that is within rounding of the yearly rate divided by 12.[1] Card rates are usually far above the rates on other debts and on what savings earn, so paying a card balance first usually saves the most.

What a lender counts

When you buy a home, the lender adds your other debt payments to the housing costs in the second ratio, total debt service, which may not pass 44% of gross income.[4] See mortgage qualification.

  • A car loan, a student loan or another loan counts at its monthly payment while anything is owed. A debt paid off before the purchase counts for nothing.[5]
  • A credit card or a line of credit counts at its payment, but no less than 3% of the balance, as an unsecured line.[6][5]

Interest on a government student loan earns a tax credit: see student-loan interest. A line of credit the plan opens itself when cash runs short is a separate thing: see borrowing when short.

See also

  • Interest on a student loan · Interest paid on a government student loan earns a federal credit at the lowest federal rate and a provincial credit at the province's credit rate (Quebec at its own rate). The plan claims it in the year the interest is paid.
  • When the plan runs short of cash · When a month needs more money than the plan has, it draws savings in a set order, then borrows on a home equity line at 5.13% and an unsecured line at 8.38%, as far as a lender would lend. When no lender would lend more, the projection stops.
  • Would a lender write the mortgage? · Lenders test a mortgage against two ratios, GDS at 39% and TDS at 44% of gross income, using a stress-test rate of the contract rate plus 2 points or 5.25%, whichever is higher. All the Numbers runs this screen on the income entered for today.

References

  1. ↑FCAC — Credit agreement for a credit card (information box example): "If interest is charged, it is calculated on your daily average balance and charged monthly to your account on the last day of your billing cycle" · A car loan, student loan, line of credit or credit card is charged its yearly rate / 12 on the balance each month, then its monthly payment comes out of cash until the balance is paid; the rate and payment stay as entered, and no new borrowing is added to it · effective 2026-10-13
  2. ↑Our convention; FCAC, Mortgage fees: Prepayment penalties ("Most lenders limit the allowed prepayment amount per year") · Simulation's "where should your next dollar go?" also pays the sum off each debt and each owned home's mortgage in the plan's first month: the balance starts lower by the sum, at most what is owed, and what is not needed stays in cash. The payment stays the same, so the loan is paid off sooner; a mortgage entered by its years left keeps those years, so its payment falls instead. A lump sum on a mortgage is taken as within the lender's yearly prepayment privileges, with no penalty · effective 2026-11-02
  3. ↑Our convention; CMHC — Calculating GDS / TDS (the payment is what a lender counts) · A debt known only by its monthly payment (a plan saved before debts were loans, or a start answer without a balance) is taken as this many months of that payment at no interest, until the real balance and rate are entered; a migrated plan's living expenses lose the same payment, since they used to include it · 60 · effective 2026-10-13
  4. ↑CMHC — Calculating GDS / TDS ("CMHC restricts debt service ratios to 39% (GDS) and 44% (TDS)") · TDS maximum (insured) · 44% · effective 2021-07-05
  5. ↑CMHC — Calculating GDS / TDS: "Other debt obligations include revolving credit (i.e. credit card debts, lines of credit), personal loans or car loans, etc."; "For unsecured lines of credit and credit cards, factor in a monthly payment amount corresponding to no less than 3% of the outstanding balance." · In a lender's debt-service test, a car loan, a student loan or another instalment loan counts at its monthly payment while a balance is owed; a credit card or a line of credit entered as a debt counts at the larger of its payment and 3% of its balance, as an unsecured line · effective 2026-10-13
  6. ↑CMHC — Calculating GDS / TDS: "For unsecured lines of credit and credit cards, factor in a monthly payment amount corresponding to no less than 3% of the outstanding balance." · In the debt-service test, the monthly payment counted on an unsecured line of credit or credit card, as a share of its balance (CMHC) · 3% · effective 2018-03-31